License agreement: entry in the Official Register

  1. Declaratory effect: the expressions used in the two provisions “The license agreement shall have effects vis-à-vis third parties…” and “It shall be effective vis-а-vis third parties…” are in this respect equivalent in meaning and it should be accepted that conscientious third parties are referred to. The lack of a recorded license agreement, for example, could be a prerequisite for (justified) objections made by third parties (offenders) for actions of the licensee against their infringement of the right on a registered mark (see Art. 73 et seq. of the Law on Marks and Geographical Indications /LMGI/).- (this function of the declaratory effect is addressed separately on purpose): Notifies the Patent Office (BPO) and other authorities involved in law enforcement in the field of trademark rights, see for example the powers of the Bulgarian Patent Office regarding the administrative penal provisions, (Art. 81 et seq. of the LMGI), the powers of the customs authorities regarding border control measures (Regulation (EU) №608/2013; Art. 78 et seq. of the LMGI); the powers of the Commission for Protection of Competition regarding the prohibition for imitation (Art. 35 of the Law on Protection of Competition) and other.
  2. Effect as proof: the recordings in the Register are considered true until proven otherwise (the burden of proof is reversed). This is the place to mention one particularly important case, related to the possibility to revoke a mark registration upon request by any person because of failure to fulfill the obligation for use (Art. 19 LMGI) and in particular in the cases where the mark is used by another person with the consent of the proprietor- regardless of the fact that by definition the “license” (granted permission) is not equal to “consent[ref]I think that license agreements, despite being the most frequent and common way for giving consent, do not exclude other forms of expressing the consent in question. Justifying this opinion would extend far beyond the subject of this piece of writing and for that reason I would only like to point out that the word “consent” is used repeatedly in the LMGI and in none of the cases can it be attributed exclusively to the form “license agreement” in the legal definition of which, not by chance, is used the word “permit”.[/ref] for use of the mark within the meaning of Art. 19, paragraph 3 of the LMGI, its recording is practically the easiest and most accessible proof of the fulfillment of the obligation for use of the mark when the same is used by a third person with the consent of the proprietor.
  3. Protective effect:

    In respect of the licensor:

    Examples: a quite common view (wrong, in my opinion) of the Bulgarian case law is that the consent (Art. 19, paragraph 3 LMGI) of the proprietor can only be expressed by means of a license agreement (Art. 22 of the LMGI). Given that it is widespread practice marks to be registered in possession of natural persons but to be used by trading companies, i.e. by persons other than the proprietor, a timely recording of the license agreement would significantly facilitate the protection against a request for revocation in its most common type (Art. 25, first paragraph of the LMGI), regardless of the fact that the recording is not a condition for the validity of the agreement. Another example is facilitating protection against actions by which the licensee or related persons seek to obtain their own exclusive rights on the mark.

    In respect of the licensee:

    – Apart from the advantages listed elsewhere in the text, only the recorded licensee should be timely notified for the proprietor’s intention (the licensor) to surrender their right on the mark. In these cases the surrender of right is recorded in the Register and has effect after the expiry of a period of two months as from the date on which evidence for fulfilment of the obligation for notification is presented.
    Only when there is a recording the licensee will be able to exercise the rights granted as a consequence to the license agreement against third parties (e.g. the right to bring infringement action, notice of opposition, granting sub-licenses).

    – In case of a non-monetary contribution in the capital of a company (a port, apportation) a license contract that is recorded in the Register would be measured at higher value.- In accordance with the proposed amendments to the First Council Directive 89/104/EEC to approximate the laws of the Member States relating to trade marks, the licensee would have the opportunity to participate in the infringement proceedings initiated by the licensor as far as damages suffered by the first are concerned.[ref]It is questionable what approach should be applied to appraisal under apportation value of a license agreement with a different licensee, as such apportation is not prohibited. I think, as the licensing agreements are commonly concluded with regard to the exact licensee and therefore, in general, the assessment in a similar kind contribution should be zero, unless the third party (licensee) is not obliged to provide the expected profit of the company in which be contributed asset.[/ref]

    – Other cases of actions from the licensor contrary to the interests of the licensee – for example in case of transfer of the rights on a mark the license agreement cannot be recordedin the Register without the consent of the new proprietor.

    In respect of the third parties:

    – Third parties contracting – the license that is recorded is a sign of the possibility that the mark proprietor does not have full rights, and conversely- when the origin of the product (goods) is recorded by the licensee the mark is most likely used properly.

    – The announcement of the license agreement in a way guarantees the consumers about who is committed to ensure the quality corresponding to the mark preferred by them.

Comments are closed.